Skip to main content

Misrepresentations of Asians

By Yongjie Li
When I firstly asked Americans about the impressions of Asians, Kung Fu and Jackie Chen are the things that they came to their minds. In fact, it cannot fully represent Asians, especially in recent developing years. According to government datas, the number of Asian Americans in USA is 21.4 million in 2016 and 6.4% of total populations (Asian-American and Pacific Islander Heritage Month, 2018), however, they are invisible in media. In order to better analysis of this situation, the impacts and stereotypes of Asians are the focuses especially in the movie Crazy Rich Asians.

Both of typical Asians and the tag of them is unchangeable during centuries. During 1840s, Fu Manchu and Charlie Chan were famous persons for Americans and represented the feminization of Asian American men, while Asian females were depicted as hypersexuality (Chyng, 2015). During 1970s, due to influences of Bruce Lee, Kung Fu became another tag on them (Chyng, 2015). Unfortunately, based on the approach to examine other racial people opinions of Asians images in media, they are still invisible, even after mass media production, and Lucy Liu, Jackie Chen and Jet Lee are typical Asians in American perspectives for continuing ten years (Chyng, 2015).

The movie Crazy Rich Asians brings new images for the public. In Tomatometer, 93% reviewers think it as fresh. It is the movie with the majority of Asians. Moreover, the previous movie The Joy Luck Club was in 1993 (Da, 2018). As a result, this movie gains a lot of public attentions which breaks the images of rigid Asians and submissive females. Furthermore, it fully depicts cultural conflicts between Asians and Americans that confuses this immigration and daily life of them in this movie. Chinese newspaper comments it as “ a great moment insteads of a movie” which means the movie brings the real cultures to the American society.

This movie indeed brings new image, however, it is not as real as whole Asians. It is because most of characters display as super-wealthy and higher-classes. Thus, materialism will be prominent and new tags for Asian Americans. On the one hand, materialism might be the problem of today higher-classes Asians, but the truth of middle-class and lower classes needs to be explored. Although the author is willing to convey that love exceeds everything, all of designers clothes, shopping and homes is 1.2 millions dollars (Ishisaka, 2018). Therefore, the focus on loves shifts to money and it cannot be a real and holonomic image. On the other hand, because of well-known movies, what might be results of this portray promotes the discrimination in mixed races society.

Even in nowadays, the misrepresentations still are prevalent in media production. I agree that “conceptual limitation” which it is about a lack of education instead of imagination (Chyng, 2015). Media becomes the one of important education in today, thus, how the producers convey ideas influences children perspectives of viewing Asians. Even though in Crazy Rich Asians provides new perspectives of Asians higher-classes images, it still brings negative point “materialism” to people who are not familiar with Asians and cannot offer sense of belongings to immigrants, thus it fully misrepresents Asians.

References
Asian-American and Pacific Islander Heritage Month: May 2018. (2018). United States Census
Bureau. Retrieved From
Chyng, S., Rachael, L., Allison, B., Sun, Y., & Rachel, W. (2015). Shifting receptions: Asian
american stereotypes and the exploration of comprehensive media literacy. The
Communication Review, 18(4), 294-314. doi:10.1080/10714421.2015.1085778
Da, X. (2018). Crazy Rich Asians. Retrieved From
Ishisaka, N. (August 10, 2018). ‘Crazy Rich Asians’ is a parallel Asian world of values I don’t
recognize, but I hope it’s a hit. Retrieved From:

Word Count: 524

Labels:

Comments

  1. KHDecember 5, 2018 at 7:50 AM

    Good work, Yongjie. You are a budding media sociologist!

    I was especially impressed that you brought in contemporary census data on Chinese people living here in the US. The lack, or invisibility as you say, of Chinese and Asians in American media is striking in light of the statistics you cite.

    Equally important, you've located, discussed and made effective use of an academic study that examines the limited but frequently stereotypical representations of Asian-American in US popular culture. Your opening paragraph featuring anecdotal evidence of Americans' limited understanding of Asian (and Asian-American) culture reinforces this study's findings.

    Finally, you offer a relatively new cultural object, Crazy Rich Asians, to consider in light of this material. The film seems to be a welcome break from routine stereotypes. But your fears that the film may inscribe yet another troubling stereotype is well taken.

    I'd like to learn more about your thinking on this. And I'm certain your classmates would benefit from a more elaborate discussion as well. Likewise, you cut short your discussion of the "conceptual limitations" afforded by US media representation of Asian-American lives and experience.

    Nevertheless, apart from some nagging issues with formatting and word choice (i.e., holonomic) this is a fine contribution to our semester-long inquiry into the relationship between popular culture and identity.

    27 pts.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

HANDS UP

By: Leda Turpen Throughout this week, my group is examining how politics have grown with the introduction of modern popular and celebrity culture in our society. While this is our main focus, I would like to shed light on an activism from the perspective of minority professional athletes, specifically the consequences they face when exercising their constitutional right to voice and demonstrate their political stances. I argue that minority celebrity athletes face a social identity threat when protesting for or against current political events, thus, are hesitant to speak up about them. Undoubtedly, our society is no stranger to the kind of reactions and responses celebrity activism can create. One prominent example being the case of Michael Brown, an African American who was shot in killed by a white police officer (Sanderson, Frederick, and Stocz, 2016). Shortly after the incident, the officer was not prosecuted, causing tension immediately (2016, p. 302). After the verdict, fi...
3 comments
Read more

THE BLACKER THE BERRY, THE SWEETER THE JUICE?

  By Aleysha Ward   “You are just as dark as the bottom of my shoe”, “Your skin color is not light enough to hang with us” and “You're so pretty for a black girl.” These are just some of the comments that black women have had to listen to while growing up. As a brown skinned black women, it is frustrating to know that my skin color will always be viewed as negative by society. Why? Well, because it is not close to a Caucasians skin color. Skin tone is a characteristic that can affect a person’s life in both positive and negative ways. Often times, our society has shown us that being of a lighter complexion or closer to a Caucasian’s skin color will provide us with benefits such as higher educational and career opportunities, a greater chance at marriage, and having the ability to be less conscious about your skin color. Although this is not true, factors as such do affect a black women’s self esteem and self efficacy. The issue of colorism continues to divide and shape the ...
2 comments
Read more

SOCIAL CLASS IN THE HUNGER GAMES: THE STRUGGLES OF THE POOR

By Griffin Spurgin The Hunger Games is an action-packed fiction book that was also turned into a movie. Throughout the series, main characters, Katniss Everdeen and Peeta Mellark are fighting for their lives in a tournament where they battle to the death of all but one tribute. They don't have much to lose as they are from District 12, the poorest district of Panem. The winners of the game get showered in riches from the Capitol and live the rest of their lives as if they were kings. A constant theme throughout the film is how the wealthy don't have to work as hard as the lower class to maintain their status. The upper and middle class are more prepared for the games just like their respected classes are in life. Class representation in film is a popular category among filmmakers. The Hunger Games portrays class in a way that resembles a lot of social systems in the world. The Hunger Games was published in 2008, at the very moment that the financial crisis was p...
3 comments
Read more