Skip to main content

LACK OF ACCESS TO MENTAL HEALTH TREATMENT SYSTEMS WITHIN THE BLACK COMMUNITY




By Cailey Griffin

The importance of mental health is not widely discussed in modern society. Even less widely discussed is the unique manner in which different ethnicities approach the topics of both mental health and mental health treatment. Often times for Black Americans, there are several obstacles when it comes to accessing mental health treatment. The HBO show Insecure explores the obstacles faced by many Black Americans when seeking mental health treatment options.

In the article “Mental Health Care Access and Treatment Utilization in African American Communities” written by Babe Kawaii-Bogue, Norissa J. Williams, and Kameron Macnear, the obstacles facing Black Americans when seeking mental health treatment options; as well as, the relationship between Black Americans and mental health in general, is further explored.

The first obstacle addressed in the article, and what I’d say is usually the most prevalent obstacle, is the sense of stigma or shame that Black Americans feel when seeking professional treatment from their family members, friends, and other members of the Black Community (Kawaii-Bogue, Williams, & MacNear, 2017, p. 14). The article also notes that the religious community/ church already serves as the source Black Americans turn to when dealing with mental health issues; as a result, if the church worked to create ties with mental health treatment services, stigma surrounding those treatment services could also be reduced (Kawaii-Bogue et al., 2017, p. 14).



Insecure is an HBO show created by Emmy nominated actress, director, and screenwriter Issa Rae. The show explores the lives of modern day Black Women in their 20’s and examines their career, love life, and friendships. In the first episode of season 2, we learn that Issa’s friend Molly has started going to therapy, but is having trouble opening up to her therapist. When Molly is describing her situation to Issa she explains she’s not opening up because she doesn’t want her therapist “in her business” (Rae, 2017). To avoid truly opening up, Molly suggests that her life is perfect and actively shoots down any potential issues her therapist tries to bring up (Rae, 2017). Molly’s behavior mimics the stigma held by a lot of Black Americans when it comes to seeking mental health treatment. Molly is uncomfortable opening up, and being vulnerable about what she’s going through because she doesn’t want to come across as “crazy” or just as much in need of therapy as others. She only shares the positive aspects of her life because she believes she can deal with all the negative elements alone.

Despite Molly’s hesitation towards mental health treatment in general, due to her internalized stigma, she does find comfort in having a therapist who’s also a Black Woman (Rae, 2017). In Kawaii- Bogue’s article one of the solutions mentioned to combat mental health treatment stigma is providing Black Americans with clinicians who are also Black Americans (Kawaii-Bogue et al., 2017, p. 14). The joy, trauma, and every experience in between, that comes along with being a Black American, is something you have to be a Black American to fully understand. If a Black American is seeking mental health treatment for an experience with racism, then they’re going to want someone who can offer advice and support from a place of mutual experience and that will often come from another Black American.
Insecure has performed so well on HBO because it accurately appeals to the experience of being a young Black American in modern society in a manner that is heartwarming, engaging, and oftentimes tastefully comical. Molly’s stigma towards seeking professional mental health treatment is something that resonates with so many young Black Americans throughout the country. Growing up in households with Black parents who lived by the mottos “Buck Up” and work through all of life's challenges taught us that we need to rely on the church, family, or ourselves when struggling with mental health issues. Despite her hesitance, Molly’s willingness to still pursue therapy demonstrates the importance of not letting stigma stand in the way of doing what’s best for you.

Keywords: Mental Health, Black Americans, Stigma, Mental Health Treatment, Obstacles

Word Count: 670

References

Kawaii-Bogue, B., Williams, N. J., & MacNear, K. (2017). Mental health care access and treatment utilization in African American communities: An integrative care framework. Best Practice In Mental Health, 13(2), 11-29.Kawaii-Bogue, B., Williams, N. J., & MacNear, K. (2017).

Rae, I. (Writer). (2017, July 23). Hella Great [Television series episode]. In Insecure. New York, New York: HBO.

Ryan, M. (2017, July 18). Photo [JPG]. Variety.com.
Labels:

Comments

  1. KHSeptember 28, 2018 at 9:59 AM

    Cailey,

    Thanks again for taking the time to revise and resubmit this post. The extra effort paid off handsomely. The post is leaner, more tightly focused, and well ordered. IMO, your post provides a fine model for your classmates to emulate in their own efforts. Here are a few more thoughts and observations.

    First and foremost, you are a fine writer. Your prose is clear and concise. Second, you've identified a relevant piece of academic literature to inform your discussion of this important TV series. Third, your discussion demonstrates good working knowledge of the show and effective application of the scholarship to inform your essay. All good!

    A few minor points moving forward. First, the short paragraph where you introduce the academic study could be stated with greater clarity. Also, work on your transition from this paragraph to your subsequent discussion of Insecure. Finally, you suggest the show's popularity stems from the fact that it "accurately appeals" to audiences. Not sure accurate is the most appropriate word choice here. Again, minor points that you can address in no time.

    In sum, Cailey, you are a fine writer. I hope your classmates read your work and emulate your approach. I look forward to reading more of your work in the near future.

    28/30 pts.

    ReplyDelete
  2. AnonymousSeptember 28, 2018 at 4:35 PM

    Cailey,

    I appreciate how you brought attention to the lack of access to mental health treatment within the Black Community as this is something I wasn’t previously familiar with.

    You did a great job connecting the academic article to the popular TV show. Your post also does a great job of explaining the show’s plot to the reader while pointing out the struggles Molly has as she decides to see a therapist. I especially liked how you used the word “crazy” when describing Molly’s situation because that is something a lot of people associate with mental health treatment and something that creates stigma around going to therapy.

    Again, I appreciate how you brought attention to this issue and think you did a great job with this post!

    ReplyDelete
  3. AnonymousOctober 1, 2018 at 3:06 PM

    Cailey,

    As Pia states, I too appreciate the attention you bring to an issue that I was originally not aware of. I applaud the connections you make between your article as well and the television show, Insecure. This show seems to me to be a popular culture object that brings individuals together, one way being the issue of mental health in the Black American community. Additionally, Insecure sheds a light on the issue for those who, like me, were in the dark before. Thank you for bringing this topic to my attention, as well as this popular culture object.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Disney Princesses: A system of commodities?

Disney Princesses: A System of Commodities?  By Katharine McLean Growing up I loved all Disney Princesses, but Cinderella was my favorite by far. I envied her long blonde hair, admired her gorgeous gown, and wished for the day that my Prince Charming would show up on my doorstep with the glass slipper that would turn me into a princess. Now, at the age of nineteen, I cannot help but look back and wonder. . . have the Disney Princesses I’ve grown up with caused me harm? I argue that the stereotypical gender norms found in Disney Princess media and the capitalist nature of popular culture leads to a narrow-minded view of femininity. In Dustin Kidd’s book, Pop Culture Freaks: Identity, Mass Media and Society , he defines popular culture in a myriad of ways, but one that stuck out to me was the idea of popular culture as a system of commodities. Kidd (2014) states, “popular culture is art, transformed into commodity, working double time as advertisement” (p. 69). This d...
6 comments
Read more

NO MORE DAISY DUKES

By Colleen Kelly This thematic series has begun to establish that female sexuality is an aspect of the music industry capable of crossing genre barriers. Country music has traditionally been labeled the genre with the least emphasis on female sexuality because of its socially conservative themes (Aubrey & Frisby, 2011, p. 477). I challenge this notion with my assertion that sexuality has always been present in country music but has undergone a change from a form of feminist liberation to a tool to objectify women. In the history of country music, particularly visible in the 1990s, there is a long-standing tradition of female artists using their music to advance feminist ideals and reclaim their sexuality (Berlatsky, 2014). Let me be clear that I am not asserting that these musicians are the long-awaited saviors of women. Rather, these female artists utilized the media to challenge societal norms surrounding gender and sexuality. Shania Twain was not only one of the biggest ...
6 comments
Read more

NOBODY CAN HIDE FROM MENTAL HEALTH

By Graham Jaeger Mental Health has played a major role in schools across the country for over the past decade. Each and every year, students feel more and more pressure as they have to adapt from their summer into new school routines (Suldo, Shaunessy, Hardesty, 2008). Students suffer from mental health largely because of stress, but other factors such as addiction, rape, and even school violence are heavy contributors as well. A perfect example of mental health issues within high school students is displayed in the Netflix television series titled 13 Reasons Why . Throughout this show, you see depression take over kids lives which ultimately has a huge impact on the rest of the students in the show. 13 Reasons Why received a lot of criticism because suicide rates in teens rapidly increased after the show was released. Many say it was due to the connection they could feel with Hannah throughout the show, and others felt like they were in her position where they felt it was the only...
5 comments
Read more