Skip to main content

BLACK LIVES MATTER... BUT WHAT ABOUT US?




by Helina Samson


People of color have played an incredibly active role in debates that erupted in both mainstream media, as well as in our everyday lives. How the media frames these movements on these social media sites however, impacts the ways in which America views these activists. Although the platform that is Black Lives Matter is heavily centered around progressive, modern day civil rights, many have turned this movement into a racial nightmare. This struggle to form discourse around race and racism is evident in popular forms of media like twitter for example.

Focusing in on twitter, the ways in which “tweets” impacted the movements in the “streets” (Kidd, 2017) are greatly attributed to the immediate reaction of #AllLivesMatter. When #BlackLivesMatter first came to trend on twitter, it was a call to action. A way of saying Black lives matter, too. However, conservative media got a hold of the hashtag and attempted to silence Black voices out of reasons of comfortability. Not only was #BLM silenced through twitter, but also on national television. Certain news channels like Fox, aired only the footage of the protests that made #BLM look chaotic. They chose headlines that made #BLM seem like a radical black nationalist group, all while pushing their agenda that not only should black lives matter, but all lives should.

You may be asking, where did all of this even begin? And why is this such a big deal in media? Who cares how things are framed if people know what is real? #BlackLivesMatter all began when a 17-year-old African American boy was murdered for simply walking back home. The man who killed him, George Zimmerman, felt “threatened” by this young black boy, a rhetoric created and further implemented by stereotypes in modern day media. As seen in the picture below, news channels like Fox News, demonized Trayvon Martin by using a photo that feeds into the “scary black man” excuse and used a photo of George Zimmerman smiling to evoke innocence. They then use words like “reportedly” and strategically say “filed against George Zimmerman” as if he is the victim in this situation.




Many users of social media, take a color-blind racist approach to tackle the glaring racial disparities we see in today’s society. “As opposed to Jim Crow era racism, color-blind racism appears egalitarian on the surface with its assertion that all people are the same” (Carney, 2016). By stating that #AllLivesMatter, the façade of a frame representing “inclusivity” is in fact framing an underlying layer of inherent racism. Twitter for example, erupted in backlash which all had a common theme of equality. However, these same sources of media who claim they want equal representation are the same ones turning a blind eye to the non-indictment of George Zimmerman. 

The ways in which media frame our opinions on topics like race and racism, is so evident, yet still sways the opinions of millions of followers. We choose to ignore the obvious lenses of bias for reasons of wanting to defend our identities and societal existence. Media outlets make it much easier to see only what you as a consumer want to see, thus creating strategic political separations. The main point of this blog was to emphasize how in a world where white voices usually control the discourse and marginalized voices are usually unheard, the Black Lives Matter movement was an attempt to reverse that rhetoric. However, the biased framing of certain news and media sources, only further separated the gap between the oppressed and the oppressors.



References


Carney, N. (2016). All lives matter, but so does race. Humanity & Society. 40(2), 180-199.


Kidd, D. (2017). Social media freaks: Digital identity in the network society. Boulder:   Westview Press


word count: 585

Comments

  1. Helina,

    This is a fine post. You focus your essay on the central (but not exclusive) role media plays in amplifying and legitimizing racism and racist discourse.

    Equally important, you make good use of the concept of "framing" to illustrate how news media shape public perception of (black) activism, such as #BLM. In future, be sure to consult some of the scholarship on this topic, especially as it relates to representations of race and racial politics.

    Apart from a few minor issues with formatting – probably the result of the difficulties you had with placing the image in your post – and few issues with APA references, this post does a fine job of stating the problem and providing a vivid illustration.

    That said, I urge to work on clarifying some of your thoughts. For instance, up top you write of "the struggle to form discourse around race and racism..."

    I get it. But this can and should be stated with greater force and clarity. The same with the discussion of reaction to BLM "out of comfortability." Seems you are pulling your punches here. It's not simply discomfort that drives this pushback, but racial animus.

    On a different note, you suggest this "rhetoric is created by the media." Again, I get it. But these sentiments exist in daily lives and everyday conversation. The media echoes, amplifies and all too often, justifies this rhetoric.

    The concluding paragraph seems to be getting at the notion of "information silos" or "information ghettos" where news and opinion reinforce existing prejudices and perceptions. Here again, you might clarify this important dimension of the problem you've identified throughout.

    In sum, this is a very fine start. I encourage you to continue to develop and refine your writing.

    28/30 pts.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Helina,
    I found your post not only impressive, but very informational. I loved reading about the Trayvon Martin story and the facts you supported on how the news had it all wrong. In this day and age, people portray news only in the way they want to see it. The sad reality of this is is that this is rarely the actual case. News stations across the country get paid to portray the news how they are told. That is their job. In all actuality, half of the things they say aren't factual evidence. I think you did a fantastic job of taking a step back from the news and diving into a certain situation just a little bit deeper. Overall, awesome job.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Helina,

    You did an excellent job taking on such a broad topic. Media's framing of black activism is certainly a large undertaking to examine, but you were successful in creating a narrow focus while still giving an brief overview of the issue at hand.

    One suggestion going forward is to take a few sentences to explain concepts that may be unfamiliar to some readers. In this case, the essay would be stronger if you had provided a brief explanation of what you understand "framing" to mean.

    What stood out to me in your post was that you were able to touch on both mainstream media framing, as in the Trayvon Martin case, and everyday media framing, such as on Twitter. By discussing both, readers walk away with a more complete understanding.

    ReplyDelete

  4. Helina,

    I applaud this post for many reasons. First, this is a topic that could be discussed in so much length, but you did an excellent job of condensing it to the number requirement. Not only did you do this, but it was done with success. The post was clear as well as informational and it was laid out very nicely. Media framing is a very large subject, but you applied it very well to your subject, and I appreciated the information pulled from Kidd's chapter that we had read in class. I especially thought your image was very powerful when combined with your post, and really hit home the claim that you were making. Overall, a very good job and a very good post!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

MISREPRESENTATION OF INDIANS IN AMERICAN FILM

By: Graham Jaeger Minorities have always been misrepresented and stereotyped within American media. More specifically, Indians have had a very hard time getting past these false depictions of themselves, especially because of how they are portrayed on television. One show that does a great job of provoking thought on the treatment of how Indian men are represented comes from the Netflix Sitcom titled Master of None . Within this show, they make it clear to the audience that the media heavily relies on a prejudiced view of Indian men. This is mainly because Indian men are often objectified as “weird and amusing” (Pfeiffer, 2016). A lot of times, the media uses these stereotypes about the Indian culture as a joke in order to make the audience laugh. Racism has been around for hundreds of years and will constantly linger for as long as I live because of this exact culture that we live in today. A major problem with racism is how the media portrays Indian men through these stereotypes...

BORN (TOO BLACK) THIS WAY

By Faith Blakey  My nighttime routine consists of scrolling through my Facebook timeline. More recently, it has been filled with social issues that are both domestic and international; from fashion, politics, to personality tests. One of the most striking posts that I have come across recently was a clip from a documentary; “So when you bleach it makes you look more nicer, look more sexier, and look more cuter than you once was”. These words from a middle aged Jamaican women describes the sentiments that are sold with the global trend of skin bleaching. Her opinions towards skin bleaching, or “bleaching”  as they call it in Jamaica, are common. This 2012 Vice documentary explores the idea that skin bleaching and colorism are practices that have  become well known and respected in popular Jamaican culture. Although this documentary reveals the deep seated colorism that is prominent in Jamaica, it seems as if colorism has developed into a worldwide epidemi...

SEXUAL MISCONDUCT IN THE WORKPLACE: HOW AN NBA TEAM FAILED WOMEN

By Joshua Mundell Sexual misconduct toward women is a growing problem in the United States. Celebrities such as Matt Lauer, Harvey Weinstein, and Louis C.K have all been found guilty of sexual misconduct within the past two years. You may ask what makes these men’s stories so similar? All these sexual misconduct incidents occurred in their respective workplaces. According to Lloyd Hoffspiegel, “There has been sexual misconduct in the workplace ever since there has been a workplace” (Hoffspiegel, 2002). One of the more disturbing cases of sexual misconduct in the workplace recently occurred within the Dallas Mavericks organization, a team in the National Basketball Association. In February of 2018, Sports Illustrated (SI) published an investigative report detailing the extensive accounts of sexual misconduct and sexual harassment that had occurred within the Dallas Mavericks organization. This report described the situation in Dallas as a “real-life Animal House” and stated ...