Skip to main content

SIDELINING THE NFL ANTHEM RULE

By Freddie Coudret

            Protesting in the National Football League (NFL) has been an extremely polarizing subject ever since Colin Kaepernick and Eric Reid of the San Francisco 49ers first took a knee during the national anthem on September 1st, 2017. Kaepernick responded to criticism by revealing that his reasoning for kneeling during the anthem was to shine a light on police brutality against minorities and social inequality. When I stated that this has been a polarizing issue since its inception- I meant it. People from all walks of life; sports fans, people who have never watched a game of football in their lives, white people, black people, and President Trump have all put their two cents in about the issue.
As a result, the NFL began working on a new rule that would require all players to stand on the field for the anthem, the alternative being a fine. Owners around the NFL, mostly older, white men, quickly voted to pass the rule in May. The rule was to be enforced beginning in the 2018-2019 season. However, back in July, the NFL player’s union filed a grievance to the NFL refuting this rule. In response, the NFL decided to table discussion of the new anthem policy for players, stating that the issue would be resolved later.
A fact that seems all too obvious these days, President Trump has been very vocal about the protests since the beginning, all the way through the tabling of the rule. The day that the players’ union filed a grievance, Trump tweeted, “The NFL national anthem debate is alive and well again - can't believe it. Isn't it in contract that players must stand at attention, hand on heart? The $40 million commissioner, meaning Roger Goodell, must now make a stand - first time kneeling, out for game; second time kneeling, out for season, no pay,” (Garcia-Navarro & Davis, 2018). It is easy to take a few quick minutes out of your day to search “NFL anthem rule,” or “NFL anthem protest,” and you’ll find hundreds of results. It ranges from major news outlets tweeting out articles about the NFL’s struggle to find a rule that can bridge the divide between everyone, celebrities and politicians weighing in on the situation, and the average American stating their opinion. Twitter is the most useful social media outlet in terms of a movement such as the one we see almost every Thursday, Sunday, and Monday nights. Major news outlets, more specifically sports media, tweet out articles for their masses of followers to see. In addition, these followers, average Americans, are very engrossed in professional football while it’s in-season. Football is what us Americans watch and talk about. When we see the protests happening right in front of us on live television and read about many celebrities and politicians responding to the protests in real time, the “tweets and the streets,” (Kidd, 2018), to pin a name to a two-faceted movement that is present in real-life and a presence on Twitter- is happening in real time. This simple act of kneeling during the national anthem, bravely started by Colin Kaepernick (whom has since been unofficially banned from the league for his actions, meaning he is doing something right), has multiplied in attention and effectiveness due to social media.

Word Count: 546








References
Garcia-Navarro, L., & Davis, W. (2018, May 27). How The NFL's New Rule On Protesting Is Being Perceived By Players. Retrieved from https://www.npr.org/2018/05/27/614810127/the-nfls-rule-new-on-kneeling
Kidd, Dustin. (2017). Social Media Freaks: Digital identity in the network society. Boulder, CO.: Westview Press.

Labels:

Comments

  1. KHSeptember 20, 2018 at 1:55 PM

    Freddie,

    In terms of formatting, this is a vast improvement. Nonetheless, your post still doesn't conform to our "house style." Issues with spacing and far too much white space between the end of your post and your reference list further undermine this effort.

    Please review this document carefully and make certain your team members review your post as well.

    More substantively, I don't see an "outside" academic source here. As mentioned several times, you are welcome to use our textbooks, but you must make use of at least one academic paper, article or book chapter you've found on your own.

    Likewise, your citation for the NPR story is incomplete. And there's no real need to cite this story if you don't mention the source in your essay. Simply cite POTUS tweet and leave it at that.

    A few other issues to consider. First, check you use of the semi-colon toward the end of the first paragraph. Second, check your use of pronouns. You write, "What us Americans do..." That should be, "What we Americans do." Again, closer proof reading on your part and quality control from your group helps avoid these errors.

    In sum, this is a timely and relevant post. Still, you would do well to follow directions more closely, proof read your work, and focus your remarks more squarely on the role that (social) media plays in this ongoing struggle between players, owners, and politicians.

    PS. As I recall, the initial NFL policy gave players another option: remain off the field while the anthem plays.

    22/30 pts.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Disney Princesses: A system of commodities?

Disney Princesses: A System of Commodities?  By Katharine McLean Growing up I loved all Disney Princesses, but Cinderella was my favorite by far. I envied her long blonde hair, admired her gorgeous gown, and wished for the day that my Prince Charming would show up on my doorstep with the glass slipper that would turn me into a princess. Now, at the age of nineteen, I cannot help but look back and wonder. . . have the Disney Princesses I’ve grown up with caused me harm? I argue that the stereotypical gender norms found in Disney Princess media and the capitalist nature of popular culture leads to a narrow-minded view of femininity. In Dustin Kidd’s book, Pop Culture Freaks: Identity, Mass Media and Society , he defines popular culture in a myriad of ways, but one that stuck out to me was the idea of popular culture as a system of commodities. Kidd (2014) states, “popular culture is art, transformed into commodity, working double time as advertisement” (p. 69). This d...
6 comments
Read more

NO MORE DAISY DUKES

By Colleen Kelly This thematic series has begun to establish that female sexuality is an aspect of the music industry capable of crossing genre barriers. Country music has traditionally been labeled the genre with the least emphasis on female sexuality because of its socially conservative themes (Aubrey & Frisby, 2011, p. 477). I challenge this notion with my assertion that sexuality has always been present in country music but has undergone a change from a form of feminist liberation to a tool to objectify women. In the history of country music, particularly visible in the 1990s, there is a long-standing tradition of female artists using their music to advance feminist ideals and reclaim their sexuality (Berlatsky, 2014). Let me be clear that I am not asserting that these musicians are the long-awaited saviors of women. Rather, these female artists utilized the media to challenge societal norms surrounding gender and sexuality. Shania Twain was not only one of the biggest ...
6 comments
Read more

NOBODY CAN HIDE FROM MENTAL HEALTH

By Graham Jaeger Mental Health has played a major role in schools across the country for over the past decade. Each and every year, students feel more and more pressure as they have to adapt from their summer into new school routines (Suldo, Shaunessy, Hardesty, 2008). Students suffer from mental health largely because of stress, but other factors such as addiction, rape, and even school violence are heavy contributors as well. A perfect example of mental health issues within high school students is displayed in the Netflix television series titled 13 Reasons Why . Throughout this show, you see depression take over kids lives which ultimately has a huge impact on the rest of the students in the show. 13 Reasons Why received a lot of criticism because suicide rates in teens rapidly increased after the show was released. Many say it was due to the connection they could feel with Hannah throughout the show, and others felt like they were in her position where they felt it was the only...
5 comments
Read more