Skip to main content

The Media Proves It



By DaBreonna Doss

When doing scholarly research, scholars have this term called “coding”. Coding refers to the ways in which language is used, but underneath this language coded images pop up in our heads about what something is or looks like. For example, when you think of the words like American, nail technician, ghetto, etc you already have a preconceived notion of what these terms mean. Now, what if we take this coded language and apply it to the word “prisoner”, or more specifically “mentally ill prisoner”?

Scholars Schilders and Ogloff (2014) in “Review a point-of-reception mental health screening outcomes in an Australian Prison” states that 32-42 percent of the prisoners in the criminal justice system are mentally ill. This is close to half the prison population, and we must look into how these prisoners’ lives play out within the system.

The question I would like to explore is, within the criminal justice system, are government agencies providing the needed care that mentally ill prisoners require and are their current approaches effective? We will be using Schilders and Ogloff text, as well as the Netflix series Lockdown which dives deep into a prisoner’s life and experience. One commonality between the two is the implications set in place to assess prisoners on their entry to a new prison or reception as scholars refer. “... some prison officials merely asking prisoners on reception a few questions about their mental health history, with other prisons utilising more comprehensive screening...” (Schilders and Ogloff, 2014, p.481). In Lockdown, they talk about the fact that many procedures as far as mentally examining new entries, get prolonged because there are so many entries within a day. Another commonality is the ways in which they handle mentally ill prisoners. In season 3, episode 6, Lockdown talks about a woman with mental bipolar disorder. In response to her disorder, she only moves cells if necessary and sometimes placed in confinement for close watch. Schilder and Ogloff (2014) point out, “Eighty-five (23%) of the severe/acute group, 78 (19%) of the suspected/stable group and 530 (62%) of those with a history of mental illness were not recorded as being referred for an additional assessment...” (p.486). To define some terminology, “severe/acute” groups refer to mentally ill prisoners that are on close rotational watch for suicide and self-harm. “Suspected/stable” groups refer to those that have knowledgeable mental health issues but is not as bad, and then there are those who simply have a history of it. There are limited resources and no room for prisoners the require mental illness assistance. “Unsurprisingly, mentally ill prisoners required substantially more services than their non-mentally ill counterparts, which suggested that standard services offered by prisons may be less suitable for mentally ill prisoners” (Schilder and Ogloff, 2014, p.488).

I suggest that rather than using government finances to set in place disciplinary confinement cells, use it to create spaces that assist mental ill prisoners and problems will begin to find solutions. Schilder and Ogloff (2014) agrees with this solution and summarizes that by giving the expenses: prisoners have less chance of relapse, they can adjust into the prison society and outside the society, have necessary and constant treatment, room will come available, and prison staff will have assistance in situations outside of their training and a much safer environment (p.490-491). All-in-all, everyone wins!




Word Count: 559

Keywords: Mental health, prisoner, lockdown, Schilder and Ogloff, room




References


Myers, W. D., & Jackson, J. D. (2010). Lockdown. Recorded Books.


Schilders, M. R., & Ogloff, J. R. (2014). Review of point-of-reception mental health

          screening outcomes in an Australian prison. The Journal of Forensic Psychiatry &


          Psychology, 25(4), 480-494.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

NOT AS PRIVATE AS YOU THINK   By Emmanuel  Koutsouras   Say you are browsing the internet, maybe reading a movie review , looking through amazon to find a video game you want .  Then you decide to go on  Instagram sometime later and see an  ad   for something closely related to that movie review or video game.  Social media is arguably the largest collective platform of information that the world has ever seen. There probably is not a single person who is completely off the grid.  Social media brings people, ideas, thoughts, facts, and opinions together, in a way that nothing else  can  do. People put so much of their personal information on the various social media platforms, assuming safety as a given. As is the case with most things in life, nothing is a guarantee,  though.  The  power of  surveillance , which when you think about it is truly disturbing is  “ that people whose personal data are ...

HOW WE GOT HERE

By Daniel Scotto For decades now, sports have played a crucial role in American culture. Out of all sports played in America, it can be argued that American Football, specifically professional football, receives the most viewership. Before the start of each game in the National Football League (NFL), it is tradition that an American flag is presented, and everyone stands in respect for our nation’s anthem. Citizens and fans embrace their patriotism as they proudly embrace what their country stands for. What does our country stand for? This is a good question that many are left pondering.  In the NFL, when the national anthem is being played, it is common for television providers to zoom in on the players to showcase their reactions. The emotions often vary among players, as some often shed tears, sing along to the anthem, or even embrace one another. One player in the NFL completely changed the way Americans view the anthem today. In 2016, Collin Kaepernick, the quarterback...

MEN DON'T CRY......RIGHT?

By: Caleb Baue     In the early studio days, masculinity looks like what is now referred to as Traditional Masculinity, where men are the dominant gender, working, providing for, and protecting the woman that are in their lives. Anything that goes against this understanding of what it means to be a man is automatically deemed as feminine. (Benshoff   & Griffin, 2009)   In the 1928 silent film Steamboat Bill Jr. , the main character played by Buster Keaton is an obvious let down to his father who is a successful, rich, business man. He then spends the entire film attempting to reach his fathers standards of Manhood. He finally accomplishes this through heroic acts of physical amazement and saves the damsel in distress. Keaton’s character makes the transition from a young college boy, with a sloppy sense of dress, no woman, no job, and no respect, to a man who is now the town hero, has a pretty girl, and shops at Men’s warehouse.(Keaton, Sheneck ...