Skip to main content

SHAMELESS: MORE THAN ENTERTAINMENT


By Natalie Raskas

Social class identification has become increasingly vague in recent years. Most Americans consider themselves middle class whether they technically qualify or not (Martin, 2018).  However, the lower class, making up around 29% of the population, is still the socio-economic minority in America (Geewax, 2015).  One could argue that most middle- and upper-class Americans have no clue about the common struggles and daily challenges members of the lower-class face. Popular culture, specifically television is one of the primary ways people are exposed to different classes, other than their own.  Sadly, such entertainment can propagate broad misconceptions about the lower class, as is evident in the wildly popular Shameless television series.

Shameless, developed by John Wells is an American TV show based on an original produced in the U.K.  The show depicts a family, “The Gallaghers,” with six children ranging from 2-24 years old, a drunkard father, and an “in and out” bipolar mother.  As the series progresses, one of the teenagers has a baby, adding to the family’s struggles. The oldest daughter, Fiona Gallagher (Emmy Rossum), ultimately raises the other children in a small house in the south side of Chicago.  Americans loved watching this struggling lower-class family drama for nine seasons.

The issue with this show is how the Gallagher family grossly misrepresented a typical lower-class family in the U.S.   Such inaccuracies shape the way viewers, especially middle- or upper-class audiences, are informed about the lower class, which helps continue the stereotypes and misinformation that are spread.  The show portrays the father, Frank Gallagher (David Threlfall), as an alcoholic drug user. Further, the rest of the family members are constantly shown purchasing alcohol and drinking, supporting a skewed view that the lower-class people are typically alcoholics. Not only in the U.S. but around the world, “within critical discourse studies (CDS) it has been observed that working-class people are increasingly being represented in the media as excessive, repulsive, or silly on the basis of both of how they behave and also as regards style choices" (Eriksson, 2016, p. 304). Throughout the series, every character becomes violent in some form, further misrepresenting what it means to be lower class.

Dustin Kidd in his book Pop Culture Freaks discusses class within television and how it is sometimes invisible, but often times only featuring middle class and upper class. In this way, Shameless does well with creating a whole show based on a lower-class family instead of just featuring a side character or two.  Importantly Kidd mentions, “even as television offers varied representations of class experience, it also distorts them (2014, p.74).



In the short clip above drugs, alcohol, arguments, child abuse, stealing, and mental health are all touched upon or shown. In three minutes, the show has illustrated what it looks like to be part of the lower class (as a viewer might interpret), so imagine what the nine seasons have done with this representation.

Other than buying alcohol and drinking daily, the characters never mention government benefits or charitable aide, which some poor or lower-class citizens often pursue assistance even when working low wage jobs. According to the 2015 U.S. Census, approximately 52.2 million (or 21.3 percent) relied on some form of assistance (2015).  Although most of the children in the Gallagher family have jobs, there are six of them. Along with a baby and a small child, they are still able to live in a house, go to school, afford food, and buy extras such as cigarettes and alcohol. The family also seems to find time to have fun. In reality, a typical American lower-class family spends their time working and possibly depending on additional government benefits to help them (food stamps, unemployment, disability, healthcare, etc.).  Somehow, this family manages to get by without any government assistance but with a great deal of alcohol and dysfunction for entertainment’s sake.

Shameless is undeniably exaggerated for comedic purposes, but producers cannot forget about the power of their platform to inform as well as to entertain. The show missed a chance to depict the realities of America’s working class in a realistic matter.


                                                                   References

Eriksson, G. (2016). Humour, ridicule and the de-legitimization of the working class in Swedish Reality Television. Journal of Language and Politics Multimodality, Politics and Ideology, 15(3), 304-321. 

Geewax, M. (2015, December 09). The Tipping Point: Most Americans No Longer Are Middle Class. Retrieved from https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2015/12/09/459087477/the-tipping-point-most-americans-no-longer-are-middle-class.

Kidd, D. (2018). Movin' on Up: Class Perspectives. In Pop Culture Freaks: Identity, mass media, and society (pp. 63-94). Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

Martin, E. (2017). 70% of Americans consider themselves middle class—but only 50% are. Retrieved from https://www.cnbc.com/2017/06/30/70-percent-of-americans-consider-themselves-middle-class-but-only-50-percent-are.html.

Masqueradeboy7 (Director). (2012, April 03). [Video file]. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yUNllG2SmFo.

U.S. Census (2015). 21.3 Percent of U.S. Population Participates in Government Assistance Programs Each Month. Retrieved from https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2015/cb15-97.html.

Word count: 680

Comments

  1. Natalie-

    I chose to comment on your post, because Shameless is one of my favorite shows. Reading your post forced me to re-examine the show from a sociological and scholarly perspective. I also appreciate your decision to write about social class representation in media, because it seems to be a facet of identity that is often overlooked. Your comment about how much was packed into the three minute clip was an especially strong part of the post.

    A few notes- I think you should have made the distinction that class is a socially determined categorization. There is not a set in stone dollar figure that determines what social class a person belongs to. Additionally I think you should spend less time summarizing the show and more time expanding on your argument.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Natalie, this is a well-researched and well-written post that adds additional insight into our discussion of class representation in (American) popular culture.

    Apart from minor issues with APA references and an error regarding lower class minority status, this essay engages with scholarship, news, analysis, as well as popular culture. (While it would be preferable to locate a study of class in US television, your point about global tendencies is well taken.)

    I especially appreciate your attention to the contradictions of this portrayal (e.g., housing, school, work, leisure, etc.) Among other things, this suggests that although Showtime is a subscription service, it adheres to advertiser-driven models of the sitcom that focus on conspicuous consumption, despite economic hardship.

    Then there's your writing. Just super! But as I mentioned last time, you do yourself and your classmates a disservice with your in-class reticence. I urge you to speak up. You've got plenty to say and you have a way of saying it.

    #JustSayin

    29 pts.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Media Proves It

By DaBreonna Doss When doing scholarly research, scholars have this term called “coding”. Coding refers to the ways in which language is used, but underneath this language coded images pop up in our heads about what something is or looks like. For example, when you think of the words like American, nail technician, ghetto, etc you already have a preconceived notion of what these terms mean. Now, what if we take this coded language and apply it to the word “prisoner”, or more specifically “mentally ill prisoner”? Scholars Schilders and Ogloff (2014) in “Review a point-of-reception mental health screening outcomes in an Australian Prison” states that 32-42 percent of the prisoners in the criminal justice system are mentally ill. This is close to half the prison population, and we must look into how these prisoners’ lives play out within the system. The question I would like to explore is, within the criminal justice system, are government agencies providing the needed care that mentall...

Bisexuality in Popular Television

By Sydney Secuskie Popular culture plays a strong role in the way teens develop and respond to their sexuality. It helps young adults develop a way to interact with their counterparts and helps them get a sense of sexuality and sexual experiences that they may experience in their young lives. However, what happens to this development when the sexuality an individual identifies with is rarely portrayed in popular films and television series? Heterosexuality is normalized within numerous popular television series, making young teens of the LGBTQ+ community struggle to find a character to resonate with. Callie Torres, a bisexual character in the TV hit show Grey’s Anatomy , exemplifies the struggles that many individuals in the LGBTQ+ community face when trying to identify their sexuality. Callie begins the first season as a straight, married female; however, she eventually falls in love with a female doctor after her divorce with her husband. Callie constantly denied her bisexual...

INFOTAINMENT: A SOURCE OF POLITICAL EFFICACY AND PARTICIPATION

By Georges Azouri Stephen Colbert, Jon Stewart, and Trevor Noah. These are all household names of television hosts on shows such as The Daily Show and The Colbert Report . Both shows are infotainment programs that inform their viewers on current news and entertain them in a satirical way. While there is great comedic value provided by these programs, there is even greater value to the political culture of the United States. Infotainment programs are not new, rather the influence they can have on an audience is new. Shows like The Daily Show or The Colbert Report share news stories and often political stories in a satirical manner. In doing so these programs are still educating audiences on politics even if it may be skewed. Political efficacy is the belief that one is able to strongly influence politics and usually is tied to political participation. A study done on adolescents showed that, “nontraditional sources of political information on television (late-night comedy) i...