Skip to main content

HANDS UP


By: Leda Turpen Throughout this week, my group is examining how politics have grown with the introduction of modern popular and celebrity culture in our society. While this is our main focus, I would like to shed light on an activism from the perspective of minority professional athletes, specifically the consequences they face when exercising their constitutional right to voice and demonstrate their political stances. I argue that minority celebrity athletes face a social identity threat when protesting for or against current political events, thus, are hesitant to speak up about them. Undoubtedly, our society is no stranger to the kind of reactions and responses celebrity activism can create. One prominent example being the case of Michael Brown, an African American who was shot in killed by a white police officer (Sanderson, Frederick, and Stocz, 2016). Shortly after the incident, the officer was not prosecuted, causing tension immediately (2016, p. 302). After the verdict, five NFL African American St. Louis Rams players locked hands and displayed a “hands-up” gesture during player introductions in reaction to the high-stake racial tensions (p. 301).
The Ram’s players actions exploded on social media, Twitter and Facebook, which allowed for users to create an array of offensive hashtags and attack the player’s actions. On both Twitter and Facebook, there was anything from an immense amount of racist remarks, referring to the players as “Thugs standing up for other thugs” (Sanderson, et al., 2016, p. 312), to users threatening the St. Louis Rams. The authors of this article conducted a study on these particular athletes’ activism, and the chaos on social media; both of which lead to two major protruding themes.
                                   Image result for athlete activism
Primarily, Pelak’s work (as cited in Sanderson, et al., 2016) describes professional athletes as social role models that can become involved in social movements through their esoteric power of becoming “agents of social change” (pg. 303). Although the authors point out that when minority athletes speak out on social issues, it often creates controversy (p. 303). First we must ask, why is this the case? The authors examine how individuals have personal and social identities, and that one’s social identity is linked to their demographic classification (Sanderson, et al., 2016, p. 306). Essentially, minority athletes are less likely to speak up because their opinion is negatively attached to their social identity, consequently, this leads society to undermine the individual’s value and further perpetuate stereotypes.
We see this today with Colin Kaepernick, former football quarterback for the San Francisco 49ers. When Nike chose him to represent their brand after the huge uproar over his decision to take a knee during the national anthem. Due to the fact that this was such a controversial decision, the attention surrounding Kaepernick was heightened. His social identity was already at stake when he began kneeling during the national anthem, but Nike’s identity is now at stake because it is perceived that they support Kaepernick’s actions. This attests to the pushback minority professional athletes get for peacefully protesting a political and social issue that specifically pertains to racism.
The consequences that arise from minority athlete activism minimize the social issues they initially advocate for. Accordingly, activism can come from anyone, although it may be interpreted differently. In particular, it is evident why minority athletes are reluctant to advocate for political issues when they are criticized for speaking up, yet also condemned when they do not. References
Sanderson, J., Frederick, E., & Stocz, M. (2016). When athlete activism clashes with group values: Social identity threat management via social media. Mass Communication & Society, 19(3), 301–322. https://doi.org/10.1080/15205436.2015.1128549 Word Count: 561

Comments

  1. Leda,

    This post makes a welcome contribution to your group's theme week on celebrity and politics. More specifically, you call attention to the difficulty professional athletes face when they take political positions in the public sphere.

    This is no small matter. Celebrities frequently wear their politics on their sleeves, but when athletes do so the "pushback" can be considerable. Note the racial dynamics in all of this – something your post doesn't directly address.

    On the upside, this is well written and supported with relevant academic literature. You make good use of this material to discuss the intersection of sport, celebrity, and politics.

    A few things for future reference. First, it isn't clear how, precisely, your using the notion of "social identity" in your thesis. It becomes clearer later in your post. You may want to "borrow" the authors' definition and use that up top of your post.

    Then there are some curious issues of word choice (e.g., "protruding themes," and "esoteric power"). I get it, but this can be stated with greater accuracy and clarity.

    In short, this is a solid effort that draws on recent events to make a welcome contribution to our ongoing discussion.

    A more concrete discussion of the racial aspect of all this, and the chilling effect criticism has on "activist" athletes, would enhance this discussion. After all Kaepernick has effectively been banned from playing because he "took a knee."

    27 pts.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Leda,

    I think your post overall helps readers understand why media activism can come with consequences depending on your identity. I really enjoyed the several different connections and that you added Michael Brown's story as a background to show how deep these online protests really go.

    As a suggestion however, maybe diving deeper into the topic of how these athletes are framed by different conservative media sites as well as the NFL in general. I believe your post would be more powerful if you included the point that this media backlash was so powerful that it swayed the opinions of some NFL team owners to not allow kneeling. This way you emphasize the importance of media activism and its backlash. But overall this was great!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Leda,
    I think it is great that you have shined light on a very relevant topic in today's society. It seems more athletes/celebs like Colin Kaepernick are not able to create the platfrom they would hope to create based on beliefs, ethnicity, etc. I also like how you integrated media activism and its effects into your post. Nice job!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

MISREPRESENTATION OF INDIANS IN AMERICAN FILM

By: Graham Jaeger Minorities have always been misrepresented and stereotyped within American media. More specifically, Indians have had a very hard time getting past these false depictions of themselves, especially because of how they are portrayed on television. One show that does a great job of provoking thought on the treatment of how Indian men are represented comes from the Netflix Sitcom titled Master of None . Within this show, they make it clear to the audience that the media heavily relies on a prejudiced view of Indian men. This is mainly because Indian men are often objectified as “weird and amusing” (Pfeiffer, 2016). A lot of times, the media uses these stereotypes about the Indian culture as a joke in order to make the audience laugh. Racism has been around for hundreds of years and will constantly linger for as long as I live because of this exact culture that we live in today. A major problem with racism is how the media portrays Indian men through these stereotypes...

BORN (TOO BLACK) THIS WAY

By Faith Blakey  My nighttime routine consists of scrolling through my Facebook timeline. More recently, it has been filled with social issues that are both domestic and international; from fashion, politics, to personality tests. One of the most striking posts that I have come across recently was a clip from a documentary; “So when you bleach it makes you look more nicer, look more sexier, and look more cuter than you once was”. These words from a middle aged Jamaican women describes the sentiments that are sold with the global trend of skin bleaching. Her opinions towards skin bleaching, or “bleaching”  as they call it in Jamaica, are common. This 2012 Vice documentary explores the idea that skin bleaching and colorism are practices that have  become well known and respected in popular Jamaican culture. Although this documentary reveals the deep seated colorism that is prominent in Jamaica, it seems as if colorism has developed into a worldwide epidemi...

SEXUAL MISCONDUCT IN THE WORKPLACE: HOW AN NBA TEAM FAILED WOMEN

By Joshua Mundell Sexual misconduct toward women is a growing problem in the United States. Celebrities such as Matt Lauer, Harvey Weinstein, and Louis C.K have all been found guilty of sexual misconduct within the past two years. You may ask what makes these men’s stories so similar? All these sexual misconduct incidents occurred in their respective workplaces. According to Lloyd Hoffspiegel, “There has been sexual misconduct in the workplace ever since there has been a workplace” (Hoffspiegel, 2002). One of the more disturbing cases of sexual misconduct in the workplace recently occurred within the Dallas Mavericks organization, a team in the National Basketball Association. In February of 2018, Sports Illustrated (SI) published an investigative report detailing the extensive accounts of sexual misconduct and sexual harassment that had occurred within the Dallas Mavericks organization. This report described the situation in Dallas as a “real-life Animal House” and stated ...